top of page
Search

The BIP39 Seed Phrase: Does it make sense converting words into numbers?


In the realm of cryptocurrency security, the Bitcoin Improvement Proposal 39 (BIP 39) plays a pivotal role in safeguarding digital assets. Introduced to enhance user experience and security, BIP 39 generates a mnemonic seed phrase, a series of words that grant access to cryptocurrency wallets. While the conventional method relies on memorizing or securely storing this series of words, an alternative approach involves saving the seed phrase as numbers. At first glance, this method might seem less secure or more complex, but upon closer examination, it's evident that saving your seed phrase as numbers is not inherently dangerous.


Understanding the Numerical Seed Phrase

BIP 39 mnemonic phrases are derived from a specific list of 2048 words, each assigned a number from 1 to 2048. This numeric assignment means that your mnemonic phrase, typically a sequence of 12, 18, or 24 words, can be equivalently represented as a sequence of numbers. For instance, a word positioned at number 100 in the BIP 39 word list would be represented by the number 100 in your numeric seed phrase.


Why Numerical Representation is Secure

The security of a BIP 39 seed phrase, whether in word or numeric form, fundamentally rests on its randomness and the astronomical possibilities of combinations. A 12-word mnemonic seed offers 2^128 possible combinations, translating into a numeric representation that's equally secure. The numeric method doesn't alter the entropy or the cryptographic foundation of the seed phrase; it merely changes the representation format. The BIP39 word list is public and easy to find because is the foundation of the protocol.


Advantages of a Numeric Seed Phrase

1. Universality: Numbers transcend language barriers, making a numeric seed phrase universally understandable. Unlike words that might require translation or could be prone to spelling errors, numbers are globally recognized, reducing the risk of errors during recovery.

2. Compactness: A numeric seed phrase can be more compact, making it potentially easier to store securely. This could be particularly advantageous in physical storage mediums where space is limited.

3. Error Detection: Numeric sequences can benefit from various error-detecting and error-correcting algorithms, potentially offering an added layer of security during the transcription or recovery process.

3. Ability to easily encrypt: By applying the Catana encryption method your seed phrase cannot be restored even if it is stolen


Implementing Secure Storage Practices

Regardless of whether you opt for a word-based or number-based seed phrase, the principles of secure storage remain unchanged. It's imperative to:

  • Avoid digital storage: Storing your seed phrase, in any form, on internet-connected devices increases the risk of theft through hacking.

  • Use physical mediums: Writing down your numeric seed phrase on durable materials, or using specialized metal backup tools, offers resilience against physical damage and decay.

  • Maintain multiple backups: Keeping several copies of your seed phrase in secure, geographically dispersed locations guards against loss due to accidents or disasters.

Embracing Diversity in Security Practices

The choice between a numeric or word-based seed phrase is more about personal preference and operational security than about inherent risk. The cryptocurrency community benefits from diverse security practices that cater to different needs and preferences. What remains constant is the need for meticulous attention to secure storage and handling practices. By understanding the security principles behind BIP 39 and adopting a method that aligns with your personal security strategy, you can effectively safeguard your digital assets.

In conclusion, while the idea of a numeric seed phrase might initially seem unconventional or daunting, its foundations are deeply rooted in the same cryptographic principles that secure word-based phrases. As we navigate the complex landscape of cryptocurrency security, it's crucial to keep an open mind about the tools and strategies at our disposal. After all, the strength of our digital asset security lies not just in the methods we choose, but in our understanding and application of these methods.

Comments


bottom of page